Disney Night on American Idol Top 5 turned out to be full of surprises. While the night was filled with magical performances and Disney classics, it ended with a twist—a double elimination that sent fan-favorite Gabby Samone and fellow contestant Mattie Pruitt home. The Top 5 finalists have now been revealed, and the race to the finale is officially on!
Gabby Samone’s Journey: A Fan Favorite to the End
Gabby Samone was one of the most beloved contestants this season. Her performances were known for their powerful vocals and heartfelt emotion. One of her standout moments was her Top 10 performance of Donny Hathaway’s “A Song For You.” The judges were blown away:
Carrie Underwood called it “absolute perfection.”
Luke Bryan said he was left “speechless.”
Ryan Seacrest praised her for mesmerizing “an entire nation.”
Disney Night Performances
During Disney Night Part 1, Gabby sang two songs:
“How Far I’ll Go” from Moana
“Home” from The Wiz
She received glowing comments, with Luke Bryan calling her first song “the clearest delivery” she’d ever given. But despite the praise, Gabby didn’t receive enough votes to make it into the Top 5. Fans could vote up to 30 times per round using her voting number, #6, but it just wasn’t enough.
Double Elimination Shock: Gabby & Mattie Say Goodbye
Gabby wasn’t the only one to leave the stage—Mattie Pruitt was also eliminated. Both contestants had made a strong impression throughout the season, and their unexpected exits left fans emotional and social media buzzing.
Magical Disney Night at Disneyland
This special two-night event saw the Top 7 perform two songs each: one Disney classic and one Mother’s Day dedication. The contestants were mentored by Lin-Manuel Miranda, adding extra star power to the week. Performances took place at the iconic Disneyland Resort, bringing even more magic to the screen.
The judges—Carrie Underwood, Lionel Richie, and Luke Bryan—offered valuable feedback, but in the end, the audience votes decided who moved forward.
Meet the American Idol top 5
After all the performances and millions of votes, host Ryan Seacrest announced the Top 5:
- Slater Nalley
- Breanna Nix
- John Foster
- Jamal Roberts
- Thunderstorm Artis
These contestants will now move on to the next round, each hoping to earn a spot in the grand finale.
What’s Next on American Idol?
With the Top 5 set, the pressure is rising. Each singer will need to give their best performances yet to make it to the final three. The next few episodes promise excitement, emotion, and unforgettable moments.
Gabby Samone’s journey on American Idol may have ended, but her talent and performances will be remembered. As the Top 5 head into the final stretch, fans can expect fierce competition and show-stopping moments. Stay tuned—American Idol Season 23 is heading toward an epic finish!
